Subject Lines Aren’t The Only Thing Affecting Your Brand’s Email Open Rates

Email marketing remains a cornerstone of customer engagement and retention strategies. As digital marketers, we often fixate on the most obvious metrics, with Open Rates being a prime focus. But what happens when these rates start to fluctuate unexpectedly?
At It's Personal, we've spoken to countless eCommerce leaders who scratch their heads over sudden changes in their Open Rates. While it's tempting to attribute these shifts to the usual suspects, there's often more to the story. Let's go deeper into the less obvious reasons behind these fluctuations and how understanding them can help you fine-tune your email marketing strategy. 

The Usual Suspects

Before we talk about the hidden factors, let's quickly revisit the most common influences on Open Rates: 

1. Deliverability Score: This is the bedrock of email marketing success. A strong deliverability score ensures your emails land in inboxes rather than spam folders, giving them a fighting chance to be opened. Low Deliverability Score will mean low Open Rates. 

2. Subject Line Effectiveness:
The gateway to your email content, subject lines can make or break your Open Rates. It's no wonder marketers spend hours crafting the perfect few words! 

While these factors are crucial, they're just the tip of the iceberg. Let's explore the less obvious reasons that could be impacting your Open Rates:

1. The Seasonal Shift
Seasonality isn't just about holiday marketing; it's a year-round consideration that can significantly impact your Open Rates. Different industries experience seasonal fluctuations at various times, for example:

• Furniture Brands: As we've observed with our clients, the summer months often see a dip in Open Rates. Why? People are more likely to be on holiday, spending time outdoors, or focusing on other activities than planning their next furniture purchase. 

• Children's Clothing Brands: Come September, there's a noticeable uptick in Open Rates. The back-to-school rush sees parents eagerly opening emails for new wardrobe ideas and deals. 

Understanding your industry's seasonal patterns allows you to set realistic expectations and plan your email strategy accordingly. For instance, a furniture brand might focus on outdoor living content during summer to maintain engagement, while a children's clothing brand could ramp up their email frequency as September approaches. 

2. Content Strategy Evolution
Your content strategy isn't static, and neither are its effects on Open Rates. When brands evolve their messaging or alter how they communicate with customers, it can have a ripple effect on engagement metrics: 

• Positive Changes: If your new content strategy resonates well with your audience, you might notice a gradual increase in Open Rates across all campaigns. Subscribers begin to associate your brand with valuable content, making them more likely to open future emails regardless of the subject line. 

• Negative Impact: Conversely, if changes in your content strategy don't align with subscriber expectations, you might see a decline in Open Rates. This could be due to a mismatch in tone, frequency, or content type. The key is to monitor these changes closely and be prepared to pivot if necessary. A/B testing different content types and styles can help you gauge what resonates best with your audience. 

3. Rapid Database Growth
Growing your email list is generally positive, but rapid expansion can have unexpected effects on your Open Rates: 

• Positive Growth: If your new subscribers are well-aligned with your target audience, you might see an overall boost in Open Rates. These engaged newcomers can lift your average engagement metrics. 

• Dilution Effect: On the flip side, if your list grows quickly with subscribers who aren't a perfect fit for your brand, it could dilute your Open Rates. These less engaged subscribers might bring down your overall metrics. The solution? Segmentation. By dividing your list based on engagement levels, acquisition source, or customer behaviours, you can tailor your content and maintain healthy Open Rates across different subscriber groups. 

Practical Steps for Navigating Open Rate Fluctuations 

Now that we've uncovered these hidden factors, how can eCommerce leaders use this knowledge to their advantage? Here are some actionable steps: 

1. Conduct Regular Audits: Don't wait for significant fluctuations to analyse your Open Rates. Regular audits can help you spot trends early and adjust your strategy proactively. 

2. Implement Seasonal Strategies: Develop content calendars that account for seasonal fluctuations in your industry. This might mean changing email frequency or content focus during certain periods. 

3. Monitor Content Performance: Keep a close eye on how changes in your content strategy affect Open Rates. Use tools like heat maps and click-through rate analysis to understand which elements resonate most with your audience. 

4. Refine Your List Growth Tactics: Focus on quality over quantity when growing your email list. Implement double opt-in processes and clear subscription preferences to ensure new subscribers are genuinely interested in your content. 

5. Segment and Personalise: Use the data you collect to create targeted segments within your email list. This allows for more personalised content, which can boost Open Rates across different subscriber groups. 

The Bigger Picture 

While Open Rates are a crucial metric, they're just one piece of the puzzle. It's essential to view them in context with other metrics like Click-Through Rates, Conversion Rates, and overall Revenue Per Email. A holistic approach to email marketing analytics will give you a more accurate picture of your campaign's success. Remember, fluctuations in Open Rates aren't always a cause for alarm. By understanding these less obvious factors, you can make informed decisions about your email marketing strategy and continue to engage your audience effectively. At It's Personal, we're passionate about helping eCommerce brands navigate the complexities of email marketing. By staying attuned to these hidden factors and continuously refining your approach, you can turn challenges into opportunities for growth and engagement. 

Have you noticed any other unexpected factors influencing your email marketing metrics this year? We'd love to hear about your experiences and insights!

 #growth #openrates #emailtips #ecommerce #dtcbrands #analytics